TEACHING IN THE WORLD OF AI: PROMISE AND CHALLENGES
What potential does Artificial Intelligence (AI) have to both advance and hamper teaching and learning? This is the theme—the driving question--of the Curriculum Study Commission’s 70th Annual Conference to be held in the fall of 2024. The question is on the mind of every educator in California and of equal concern to The United States Office of Educational Technology.
Today, many priorities for improving teaching and learning have gone unmet, so it is natural for educators to actively explore AI tools as they are newly released. The opportunities seem boundless—from speech recognition for students with disabilities, as well as multilingual learners and others who could benefit from greater adaptability and personalization, to the unlimited potential for learning across the curriculum, formative assessment, coaching and even counseling. But technology must always bein the service of learning, and there are great risks: AI tools often fail to develop a deep, intuitive understanding of a task-ranking systems, for example, are often faulty because machine learning can’t consider variables that have not been fed into its system. Risk of academic integrity is another immediate risk, violations of privacy, and unethical results of AI use, as well. The CSC 2024 Conference is poised to address proactive policies through access to AI experts, in-depth panel discussions, and full-weekend sessions organized by topic. Examples include sessions on teaching, such as how AI might improve the quality of educators’ day-to-day work; sessions on learning, such as the extent in which AI enables adaptions to students’ strengths and not just their deficits; and sessions on assessment, for example, exploring formative assessments that bring benefits to the students’ learning experiences.
AI is not a thing, rather it is “any computational method that is made to act independently towards a goal based on inferences from theory or patterns in data” (Friedman, et al., 2021)i It is up to humans to determine the types and degree of responsibility we will grant to technology within educational processes. That is our current dilemma and challenge, both of which the Commission is poised to address.
Robert Jeffers is a 22-year education veteran. Currently principal of the largest continuation and community day school in the Los Angeles Unified School District, he has also served communities in Los Angeles as an instructional coach, a support administrator, and a teacher.
During his award-winning teaching tenure, he earned multiple Teacher of the Year recognitions and commendations from community leaders. His students were accepted to more than 70 universities including most Ivy Leagues. Additionally, he helped students collectively garner more than $9 million in scholarships. He’s overseen well-above 10,000 collective hours in community service projects at more than 100 events.
He has taught in Sri Lanka and Sierra Leone plus fostered partnerships with corporate and non-profit organizations across industries from art to filmmaking to science. Artificial Intelligence in education poses a generational opportunity and challenge for students and educators alike requiring presence, awareness, creativity, humility, vision, industry, and critically, community.
1. Practical Questions and Critical Conversations About AI
GRADES 6-12, COLLEGE, GENERAL ENRICHMENT
Beyond easy answers, what impact will AI, including large language models like ChaptGPT, have on marginalized students? Will it provide access and equity like never before or will it replicate, or magnify, the inequities that fundamentally shape public education? Instead of waiting to find out, enter conversations to build an understanding of algorithms and LLMs to envision classroom, school, and district policies centering on student interests. Participants will be grounded in critical theories from Anyon (1981), Hammond (2014), Nobel (2018), Howard (2020), Perez (2021), and Hicks (2023). We will center ourselves in a judgment-free, experiential space to investigate relationships with technology and to critically investigate the roles it may play in our careers, classrooms, and districts.
2. From Literature to Using ChatGPT and other AI Tools to Support Student-led Inquiry
GRADES 6-12
This session demonstrates using young adult literature, such as "Flowers For Algernon," to foster empathy and creativity in classrooms. Participants experience a project-based unit where students explore disabilities, becoming "Inventors of the Year." They brainstorm disability-related products, research using AI tools and credible websites, sketch prototypes, write product descriptions, and create guides. The unit culminates in an "Invention of the Year Expo" and reflective blogging. Besides disabilities, the session discusses literature addressing issues like gender, race, nationality discrimination, and socio-economic gaps. Participants will then develop or bring their own unit, culminating in a group session to share and discuss their work.
3. Do You Have to be Human to Understand Hamlet?
GRADES 9-12
In our session, we will do our own analysis of Shakespeare's Hamlet, and compare it to analysis produced by Artificial Intelligence. We'll ask ourselves, if AI were a student in our class, how well would it do with understanding the themes and character motivations in the play? Could it do insightful analysis, write a provocative thesis, provide thorough evidence and persuasive commentary? How would it do on high school level assessment questions? In the process of engaging the artificial mind of a machine, we will ask ourselves, what does it mean to be human?
OPTIONAL PRECONFERENCE READING: Hamlet by William Shakespeare
4. Engaging with ChatGPT: Co-Active Emergence
GRADES K-12, COLLEGE, GENERAL ENRICHMENT
Students have always found ways to access learning aids that teachers discourage. From smuggling CliffsNotes into their backpacks to selling essays, from keyword searching assignments to scanning math problems, they've consistently tried to work the system. In this digital age, educators have tried implementing plagiarism checkers and even hanging cell phone pouches on the wall. With the advent of AI, however, the dam has burst, and those prevention strategies no longer address the flow of information and answers streaming toward kids. So, what does it look like to teach and learn and collaborate in the Age of AI? https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Bryan-Sanders
PRECONFERENCE READING: EngagingEngaging with AI -- A radical shift for the future, today; Attention is all you need
5. Assessing, Learning and Applying AI
GRADES 6-12, COLLEGE
In this session, participants will learn about AI tools, and share experiences and understanding of the tools in their classroom. Together, we will create a resource bank of tools for use and work on an assessment guidance tool that can be used by teachers and students as we navigate the use of AI in our daily lives.
6. Teaching Klara and the Sun CANCELLED
GRADES 9-12, COLLEGE
This session will explore an approach to teaching Kazuo Ishiguro's novel Klara and the Sun, which explores the integration of AI "friends" into family life, and ultimately what it means to be human as increasingly better facsimiles are developed.
PRECONFERENCE READING: Klara and the Sun by Kazuo Ishiguro
7. Creative Writing and AI: Fostering Wonder Ethically CANCELLED
GRADES 6-12, COLLEGE
AI systems glean creative works from the internet and have been employed to create new works of literature To create new writing means certifying that your work does not contain generated language. In this interactive workshop we will demonstrate how to involve AI in the creative writing workshop ethically. All creative writing instructors, writers, and enthusiasts are invited to join us.
8. AI and the Student Centered Classroom
GRADES K-12
This session will explore ways in which new technologies can contribute to advancing a student centered, learning by doing, project-based curriculum. Drawing on the pathmaking work of James Moffett, participants will deepen their knowledge of the universe of discourse and explore methods of engaging students holistically in writing and learning.
9. AI in the Language Arts Classroom: The Social Justice Edition CANCELLED
GENERAL ENRICHMENT
The impact of AI in academia has be HUGE and when we consider how the social justice aspect of classroom dynamics alongside AI, what does this look like, how can we best direct the outcomes of excellence we want our students to leave us with now that Google and other search engines are now supercharged with AI. How do we embrace the technological advances AI brings us as educators in an equitable more teacher-friendly way? Let's discuss some of the social justice challenges and successes AI brings to the everchanging dynamic of our classrooms.
PRECONFERENCE READING: Understanding Education for Social Justice; The Ethics of Artificial Intelligence
10. Future-Proofing English Education: Empowering Students for AI-Infused Career Landscapes
GRADES 9-12
This session will take a deep dive into how we can prepare our students in a way where they can see the real world applications of the classroom skills we teach them today, from learning how to properly and responsibly prompt LLMs, to how they can use the tool to help organize themselves.
Artificial intelligence is here to stay, and we are only in it's infancy stages. As teachers, we have a responsibility to prepare our students not just for the world of today but the job market they will enter into 5 to 10 years from now. Learn how you can infuse your classroom with skills for students to be equipped for that world. From learning how to properly and responsibly prompt LLMs to how they can use to the tool to help organize themselves, this session will take a deep dive into how we can prepare our students in a way where they can see the real world applications of the classroom skills we teach them today. Participants expected to have working experience with AI.
11. English Instruction Evolved: Tips and Tricks for Fast-Curriculum Design
GRADES 6-12, COLLEGE, GENERAL ENRICHMENT
This workshop equips English teachers with strategies to integrate ChatGPT into their lesson planning process, specifically through designing activities, setting objectives, differentiating instruction, and assessing with AI.
In November 2022, OpenAI (OpenAI, 2023) launched a transformational large language model (LLM) technology trained on 45 terabytes of data to understand typed prompts and generate written content that sounds human. And while critics note many problems with what is essentially a superpowered autocomplete tool—inaccurate results (Heaven, 2022), the potential for one-click plagiarism (Keegin, 2023), and bias (Cousins, 2023)—many scholars celebrate the capacity of generative AI to save teachers time and enhance their impact (Nerantzi, et. al., 2023). Because practices for successfully using AI in the classroom are currently in the “Band-Aid” (Langreo, 2023) phase, the facilitators propose a methodology for exploring ChatGPT’s potential as a curriculum planning tool for English teachers. Specifically, we will scaffold approaches for using ChatGPT (the free version) to brainstorm instructional approaches, make data-based decisions, plan whole class discussion prompts, sequence skill- and content-building activities, differentiate instruction, and ultimately write lesson plans aligned with appropriate standards. Participants will explore the specific capabilities and limitations of the AI tool as we shift from the age of teacher-invented materials to AI-invented materials with teacher reflection and modifications. PRECONFERENCE READING: AI Text Generators - Sources to Stimulate Discussion Among Teachers; Practical AI for Instructors and Students Part 1: Introduction to AI for Teachers and Students
12. In the Belly of the Beast: Why We Need to Put Ethics First in the Age of AI
GRADES 9-12
Rather than enforcing a top-down AI policy in the classroom, we will grapple with questions surrounding AI and design morally responsible guidelines for writing, reading and research. We will explore the intricacies of storytelling and moral philosophy through contemporary writings, and disucss ways our students will critically analyze texts, employing close readings and discussions to understand authorial styles and intentions. The session includes creative writing tasks, discussions on moral education, and explorations of ethical dilemmas in technology. A Socratic Seminar will further examine the impact of AI and the role of human struggle in the digital age, encouraging students to reflect on their moral compass in today's world. OPTIONAL PRECONFERENCE READING: “How America Got Mean” by David Brooks, The Atlantic August 14, 2023; “You Are Not a Parrot and a Chatbot Is Not a Human” by Elizabeth Weil, New York Magazine March 1, 2023; “Issue 248” by Nick Cave, The Red Hand Files, August, 2023.
13. I’m Nobody. Who are You?: Writing, Reading, and Writing About Poetry
GRADES 9-12, COLLEGE, GENERAL ENRICHMENT
How do we engage with and teach poetry? Beyond Dickinson's "I'm nobody," we explore "Who are you?" to uncover identity in poetry. This foundation guides our study of poems, teaching methods, and prompts, deepening our poetic practice and instruction.
14. Generative AI: Implications for Teaching in the Age of ChatGPT CANCELLED
GRADES 6-12, COLLEGE, GENERAL ENRICHMENT
How can we best equip our students for a future that includes generative AI? What are the practical and ethical considerations of AI? How will this change what we can and should be doing as teachers? This session will dive into these questions and more as we adjust to a new frontier.
With generative AI increasingly accessible, students face a significant disadvantage if they graduate without understanding effective and ethical uses of AI. This session will include demonstrations of AI's capabilities, examples of misused AI in student work, and strategies for responding. We'll explore practical classroom strategies to engage students in understanding AI's implications, and consider how educators' responsibilities might evolve. This interactive session invites diverse perspectives, from enthusiasm to concern, about AI's role in Language Arts. It's a collaborative exploration of AI's current and potential impact on our profession and our students' lives. Participants expected to have working experience with AI.
15. John Steinbeck in Conversation with AI: Mapping a Vision of Interconnectedness
GRADES 6-12, COLLEGE, GENERAL ENRICHMENT
This session delves into human nature themes, paralleling AI's quest to mimic human intelligence and behavior. It draws parallels between Steinbeck's works, like "Grapes of Wrath," "Of Mice and Men," and "Cannery Row," which comment on poverty, inequity, and industrialization, and AI's potential societal impacts. The session explores how AI might worsen or mitigate social inequities, reflecting current AI industry debates. We'll examine Steinbeck’s philosophy, his characters' resilience and adaptability, and his emphasis on interconnectedness within communities. This session links Steinbeck's themes with contemporary AI discussions, highlighting their relevance to our interconnected society. Bring your favorite Steinbeck novel or writing.
16. Exploring Intersectionality in Climate Change Literature and Film CANCELLED
GRADES 9-12, COLLEGE
Climate change is the most pressing existential threat of our time. Join us for an interdisciplinary discussion of climate change literature and the way it intersects with race, gender, and socioeconomic status. We will explore poetry, novels, films, and critical theory related to climate change and the environmental humanities.
PRECONFERENCE VIEWING: Beasts of the Southern Wild
OPTIONAL PRECONFERENCE READING: Counting Descent by Clint Smith, Salvage the Bones by Jesmyn Ward, and A Children Bible by Lydia Millet.
17. Pivot, Not Surrender: An Approach To Generative AI
GRADES 9-12, COLLEGE
In the era of large language models (LLMs), English language arts teachers ponder how to adapt their teaching. Writing, traditionally a measure of intellectual skill, faces challenges from chatbots that mimic student work. This session aims to comfort and challenge educators, addressing technology’s impact on education. Discussions will cover concerns, instructional implications, and ethics in an AI—inclusive world. Emphasizing a “pivot, not surrender” approach, it explores how educators can integrate modern technologies yet preserve writing’s educational value. Teachers will leave with a broad perspective and practical strategies for classroom integration. Participants expected to have working experience with AI.
18. Classroom Management: IRL CANCELLED
GRADES K-12
The classroom is the place where the magic of education happens, or doesn’t. This weekend, I would like to invite you to engage in a conversation of and for implementing strategies, routines, and mindful structures that will help organize a thriving learning space for every student and teacher.
19. All Your Faves Are Problematic: Directly Addressing Problematic Actions, Ideas, and Content In Our Classrooms, Departments, and Schools CANCELLED
GRADES 6-12
Many of us teach texts, use grading systems, or employ department policies that have some problematic elements- sometimes out of habit, sometimes we’re required to. Let’s spend the weekend discussing and examining what we teach and how, and surfacing strategies to identify and address these problems and how we can evolve our curriculum, our classrooms, and our schools, including sharing and developing approaches we can immediately start using back at school.
20. Cultivating Authentic Writers in an AI World
GRADES 9-12, COLLEGE, GENERAL ENRICHMENT
How do we turn reluctant writers into confident authors when LLMs are a click away? What tools do we have at our disposal, and how do we best deploy them? In this session, writing instructors will share best practices and illustrative failures pertaining to that unstated part of our job description that requires us to convince students to earnestly engage tasks that AI can do in seconds. We will examine the role of writing in our curricula and discuss methods for generating student buy-in. Our conversation will include course design, assignment structure, classroom management, trust building, feedback techniques, and more.
21. AI and Journalism. CANCELLED
GRADES 9-12, COLLEGE
Does AI offer journalists a moonshot opportunity or pose a threat equal to the Internet, dictatorships, and media consolidation? The truth is somewhere in between. How AI impacts academic classrooms and newsrooms dominates journalism conferences. Join the conversation and learn ways active journalists work in this new era.
22. AI is my New TA
GRADES 6-12
With countless artificial intelligence platforms emerging, there is a growing opportunity for educators at all levels and stages in their careers at our fingertips. This session will focus on time saving strategies for lesson planning, providing quality feedback, adapting and creating content, and building assessments, all with the support of various AI platforms and tools. We will explore MagicSchoolAI, ChatGPT, Quizziz, Brisk, and more. We have all felt the need for more time, extra support, and collaboration. In its own limited way, AI can provide these supports as we continue our meaningful work. Let AI be your new TA.
23. From Life to Paper: Telling Stories with a Little Help from AI CANCELLED
GENERAL ENRICHMENT
We are the experts when we wrote our personal stories. AI may help us with some details. In this session you will be invited to write and share two or three life vignettes. Participants will receive more than 100 writing prompts.
24. Writing on the Road
GRADES K-12, COLLEGE, GENERAL ENRICHMENT
Through writing, we gain the ability to understand our lives and to find our place in the world. In this workshop, we engage in a non-threatening writing process developed by the Bay Area Writing Project which transfers easily to the classroom. We remember the thrills and challenges of creating, and explore methods for sharing and revising early drafts. On Saturday morning, participants work independently (“on the road”), creating memoirs, essays, poetry, or fiction. Later, we gather in small groups to read our work and offer feedback. On Sunday, we regroup to enjoy each other’s creations and celebrate the creative journey.
25. The Opera Group CANCELLED
GRADES K-12, COLLEGE, GENERAL ENRICHMENT
As far as we are concerned, opera is the pinnacle of performance art, an extreme sport which rewards both the novice and seasoned opera goer with a multitude of riches. If you wonder what opera is about, we cover that. If you like exploring literary themes, we cover that. If you like classical music, you’re in. Opera rewards those with prior knowledge, and this group provides that, not only for two upcoming operas in San Francisco (so you can buy tickets), but for enjoyment of opera for all time. A 30-year fixture of the Asilomar conference, the opera group covers a lot of bases, but focuses on two upcoming performances of the San Francisco Opera. We compare and contrast performances from all over the world on DVD to illuminate the world of opera. Perfect for novice and pro alike.
26. Do Your Own Thing! Team Planning Session
School or district reams can use the conference time to plan their own projects. Groups often find inspiration from the keynote and Around the Hearth sessions.
Friday, OCTOBER 4
3:30-9:00 pm Registration (Chapel)
4:30-5:30 pm Reception (Scripps Patio)
6:00-7:00 pm Dinner
7:15-8:30 pm General Session A--Keynote (Chapel)
8:45-9:45 pm GROUP SESSION #1
Saturday, OCTOBER 5
7:30-8:45 am Breakfast
8:00-5:45 pm Bookstore Open (Scripps)
9:00-10:30 am GROUP SESSION #2
10:30-10:50 am Coffee Break (Kiln and Curlew)
10:50-12:00 pm GROUP SESSION #3
12:00-1:00 pm Lunch
1:30-3:00 pm GROUP SESSION #4
3:00-6:00 AI Test Kitchen (Chapel)
4:00-5:30 pm Reception and Book Signing (Scripps Patio)
6:00-7:00 pm Dinner
7:15-8:30 pm Around the Hearth Session I w/Carol Jago (Kiln)
8:45-10:00 pm Around the Hearth Session II: Open Mic (Kiln)
Sunday, October 6
7:30-9:00 am Breakfast
*Pick up boxed lunch orders after breakfast
8:00-9:00 am Bookstore Open
*Check-out @11am--Luggage storage available (Front Desk/Social Hall)
9:15-11:15 am GROUP SESSION #5
12:00-11:00 Lunch
REGISTRATION
Early bird registration deadline has passed. Registration closes September 1, 2024. Register early to ensure lodging at the Asilomar Conference Grounds! Link to Registration.
CATE Member Registration $375
NON-CATE Member Registration $425
ACCOMMODATIONS
The accommodation fee includes two nights’ lodging and six (6) meals (Friday dinner, served from 6-7pm, through Sunday lunch). If you choose a SHARED ROOM--you and your roommate must provide each other’s names in the registration form--we will not be partnering attendees). Participants lodging off-grounds must pay the off-grounds fee because Asilomar provides meeting rooms paid in part by lodging fees. Off-grounds fee does not include meals; to add meals choose off-grounds w/meals, an additional $220 (six meals).
Single Room + Meals $650 Off-Grounds $85
Shared Room + Meals $430 Off-Grounds + Meals $305